I wasn’t kidding when I had our lawyer draft into our family trust that our children cannot institutionalize us for old age. Obviously, we hope to raise them so that thought is horrifying to them without necessitating pointing my eventual bony, wrinkly finger to black ink and signatures, but we put it there to prove a point early: this family takes care of each other. This logic didn’t start with me. I grew up in an inter-generational household. That is how it has always been done, and that is how it will remain. I will entrust myself to my children as they have been entrusted to me. God-willing, I will help them care for their babies, and this cycle Instagram keeps telling me is toxic family behavior will continue for all our days.
Think I’m placing an undue burden on my children? In January 2025, 97-year-old Dorothy Benesh was living at a Pasadena assisted-living facility during the Eaton fire. Residents had been instructed to stay in their rooms until staff came for them. Staff evacuated the building, but nobody came for Benesh. Her son Jim called, realized she was still inside, drove through the evacuation zone, entered the empty facility, and found her alone in her third-floor room with fire outside the window. He got her out himself. The facility did not contact him to confirm her whereabouts until hours later.
Family dependence has never moved in one direction. It shifts across a lifetime according to who needs help and who has the capacity to give it. Grandparents do reorganize their lives around grandchildren, parents make room for adult children returning home, siblings assist one another through a hard season. Americans provided roughly 36 billion hours of unpaid family caregiving in 2021, work AARP valued at about $600 billion. However, research on Medicaid long-term-care eligibility found that when formal coverage, meaning expanded program funding, became easier to obtain, elderly parents became less likely to live with adult children and nursing-home use increased. Increase the program, increase institutionalization. We’re being shuffled out of family solutions and into government sponsored programs. Can you guess what’s about to happen with daycare?
Increasingly, families have less room to absorb the cost of dependence. Government intervention chronically inflates prices, decimating optionality. The New York Fed found that each additional dollar of subsidized federal loan capacity was associated with about 60 cents in higher tuition, roughly $600 in tuition for every extra $1,000 students could borrow. Families got more aid—and a higher price tag. Housing research conducted through the American Economic Association found larger vouchers were captured through higher rents, with little improvement in housing or neighborhood quality. We keep outsourcing affordability to institutions, then living with the higher prices and spending those systems produce. Removing the market disincentivizes value.
A program out of Cleveland, Ohio, called RxKids launched September 1 in three ZIP codes, boasting paying $1,500 during pregnancy and $500 monthly for six months through a public-private partnership backed by the City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County and the county Board of Developmental Disabilities. Its own policy playbook instructs jurisdictions on using TANF (cash assistance) by treating late pregnancy and childbirth as periods of “acute economic hardship.” This is an abysmal premise: a predictable familial need becomes the basis for a recurring administrative income stream. Once we accept that premise, program expansion becomes the obvious response whenever family life proves expensive.
Families surrender more of their income to collective systems, encounter prices shaped partly by those systems, lose the financial margin required to rearrange their own lives, and then require formal provision because private provision is insufficient to keep up with escalating costs of family life. “We can’t afford kids” is a new slogan for this generation of young adults, and I’m not buying in to the inevitability laced over that statement. Poor government spending produces the privation that made families less capable of meeting their own financial needs in the first place.
A healthier culture would recover the dignity of being useful to one’s family. Longitudinal research found that stronger filial-duty norms predicted greater support for parents as their health declined. Multigenerational research also found that parents transmit those norms to their children. Obligation learned inside the family helps keep care there. Kids watch a grandparents restructure their week around them. Aunts show up at the field and cheer passionately for nieces and nephews. Siblings pool money, change plans, share cars, bedrooms, and time. Belonging to a family creates obligations with material consequences.
Obligatory family care is essential, even sacred. It builds a form of wealth no entitlement program can appropriate and redistribute: people habituated to showing up for one another. The more we impoverish families of reasonable access to obligation, the more indispensable institutions will appear. We need to accept that being needed is part of our inheritance.
Institutional dependence becomes self-perpetuating. When the state assumes more of the work families once organized across generations, children inherit fewer examples of what they owe their own. A family legacy is built by learning obligation and contributing to the future. Once that inheritance is surrendered, no public program can restore it for us.
Jillian Tymo is a writer and the host of the podcast “Rebranding Motherhood,” founded by Dr. Abby Johnson and produced by ProLove Ministries. She examines culture, politics, and religion through her work and academic studies at Georgetown University.
Instagram: @jilliantymo @rebrandingmotherhoodpodcast